Canada is second country to pull out of Youth Olympics swimming competition

Uh-oh, it looks like the Americans aren’t the only ones who will not be competing in the swimming competition of next year’s Youth Olympic Games.

The Canadians are following suit.

According to a report in The Straits Times today, Swimming Canada, the national body for the sport in the country, has decided that the Junior Pan Pacific Championships, which will be held in Hawaii from Aug 26-30, would be a more suitable competition for their top youth swimmers than the YOG.

No swimming for Canada and the US at next year's YOG

 What do they mean by that? Well, this is their explanation for not competing in the YOG:

After much deliberation Swimming Canada has determined that it is not strategically appropriate to attend the first Youth Olympic Games in Singapore.

“There were many factors leading to this decision, amongst them being a conflict with the dates for our primary summer competition, the Junior Pan Pacific Championships.

Suffice to say the key reason for our decision was to ensure our athletes are exposed to the best possible competitive and developmental opportunity. We’re confident that the Junior Pan Pac’s will provide the challenges our athletes require.”

You can find out more at this link.

Back in September, it was reported that  USA Swimming decided to pull out its swimmers of the YOG because it preferred to send them to qualifying meetsfo the senior and Junior Pan Pacific Championships. It also said that it felt that the YOG was more a’world peace and education programme’, than it is about ‘high-level competition’.

 Since then, the Singapore National Olympic Council and the Ministry of Community Development, Youth and Sports have been at pains to stress that the YOG will feature high standards of competition. But it looks like the Canadians are not convinced.

Here’s something for us to ponder: if the US and Canada have decided to focus on the Junior Pan Pacific Championships instead of the YOG, then isn’t there the strong possibility that other countries that regularly compete in the Junior Pan Pac might do the same.

I checked out the list of competing nations at this year’s Junior Pan Pac which was held in Guam. The 14 countries included traditional powerhouses such as China, Japan, Australia and New Zealand.

Here’s another thought: Even if these countries do send their swimmers to the YOG, how can we be sure that they will be the cream of their crop?

After all, the YOG has only allowed each country to send two boy and two girl swimmers. Who is to say that some of the countries competing in the unior Pan Pac might not be tempted to send their second-tier swimmers to the YOG to make up the numbers?

Yours in sport

Singapore Sports Fan

Related posts:

28 Sept 2009: The US pulls out of YOG’s swiming competition…

Tagged , , , , , ,

8 thoughts on “Canada is second country to pull out of Youth Olympics swimming competition

  1. […] View post: Canada is second country to pull out of YOG swimming competition … […]

  2. marissab says:

    Pan Pacs has always been an important competition for the countries involved, so, no surprise

    Therein lies the problem behind YOG. There is no history and precedence behind this. Countries will always choose to go for other competitions that they have always been in, especially if there are clashes in schedule

  3. marissab says:

    Another reason for Canada and US completely pulling out might be because Hawaii is so near to them. AUS, NZ, JPN and CHN are nearer to us, so they might send some swimmers over still.

    But I wouldnt be surprised if it is their “B” squad that comes to YOG, and the “A” squad goes to Pan Pacs. Especially AUS, JPN and CHN who have enough depth to do that. Just look at the recent Asian swimming champs: Japan concentrated on the East Asian Games and sent their “B” squad to the Asian Champs

  4. sportard says:

    thanks for this post. after all the big hooha, now then i see the real “importance” of yog. lol

  5. matt says:

    the other thing to consider here is that swimming tends to be a young persons sport. Unlike most sports, world and Olympic champions tend to be around the world mark in their teens and its not rare to seen the worlds best being below 20…..

    In fact you could say, from Australia, USA etc anyone who older than 16 and is going to be a world beater is already in the senior team.

    You wouldn’t expect to people who are already mixing it with the big kids to be at a minor event like the YOG when another major event is on.

  6. […] everything – Singapore Sojourn: Early Singapore – Before Raffles – The Singapore Sports Fan Says: Canada is second country to pull out of Youth Olympics swimming competition – Reclaim Land: Barber in the alley [via TOC] – Ian On The Red Dot: Welcome To Singapore … […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: